Skip to content

Bar Keepers Friend vs Comet: The Cleaning Showdown!

Bar Keepers Friend vs Comet The Cleaning Showdown!

Cleaning our homes is a necessary but often tedious task. Luckily, there are cleaning products like Bar Keepers Friend and Comet that aim to make our lives easier. In this article, we’ll explore the choice between these two products and help you determine which one suits your cleaning needs best.

Bar Keepers Friend, an underdog in the cleaning world, shouldn’t be overlooked. With a rich history dating back to 1882, it utilizes a unique combination of oxalic acid and polishing agents to tackle even the toughest stains. On the other hand, Comet has been a trusted household name for over 50 years. Known for its bleach-based formula, it has a reputation for effectively cleaning various surfaces, from sinks to toilets and stovetops.

Choosing the right cleaning product is essential to ensure efficient cleaning and avoid potential damage to your home. Before reaching for the nearest or cheapest option, take a moment to consider which product will deliver the best results for your specific situation. In this article, we’ll delve into a detailed comparison between Bar Keepers Friend and Comet, providing you with the information you need to make an informed decision. So, let’s begin by exploring each product individually and discovering the strengths they bring to your cleaning routine.

Bar Keepers Friend: The Underdog

Bar Keepers Friend The Underdog

History and Background of Bar Keepers Friend

Bar Keepers Friend may not be as well-known as some other cleaning products, but it has been around for over 100 years. That’s right, this little gem has been helping people clean up after themselves since 1882. It was originally created to clean the pots and pans in the kitchens of professional chefs, but soon became popular with homeowners as well.

Over the years, Bar Keepers Friend has evolved from just a kitchen cleaner to an all-purpose cleaner that can handle almost anything you throw at it. Its versatility is one of the things that sets it apart from other cleaners on the market.

Unique Ingredients That Set It Apart from Other Cleaning Products

One of the unique ingredients in Bar Keepers Friend is oxalic acid. This makes it especially effective at removing rust stains and hard water buildup. Unlike some other cleaners that contain harsh chemicals like bleach or ammonia, Bar Keepers Friend is non-abrasive and safe to use on a variety of surfaces.

Another ingredient that sets Bar Keepers Friend apart is its micro-abrasive particles. These tiny particles help scrub away dirt and grime without scratching delicate surfaces like stainless steel or porcelain.

Advantages of Using Bar Keepers Friend Over Other Products

If you’re tired of using harsh chemicals to clean your home, then Bar Keepers Friend is definitely worth trying out. Not only is it non-toxic and environmentally friendly, but it also works wonders on tough stains and build-up. One advantage that I personally love about Bar Keepers Friend is its ability to restore old cookware back to its original shine.

If you’ve ever inherited or found a rusty old cast-iron skillet at a garage sale, then you know how difficult it can be to clean. But with Bar Keepers Friend, you can bring that skillet back to life in no time.

Overall, Bar Keepers Friend may be the underdog in the cleaning product world, but it’s definitely a product worth trying out. Its unique ingredients and versatility make it a favorite among many homeowners and professionals alike.

Comet: The Classic

Comet 73163 Crème Deodorizing Cleanser

History and Background of Comet

Ah, yes. The classic.

The household name that has been around for decades. But just because it’s been around for a while, does that mean it’s the best?

Absolutely not. Let’s take a look at the history and background of this so-called “classic”.

Comet was first introduced in 1956 by Procter & Gamble. It was marketed as an all-purpose cleaner that could be used on everything from countertops to toilets.

At the time, it was revolutionary – but now, it’s just outdated. Despite its long-standing presence in households across the country, Comet has had its fair share of controversies over the years.

In 2016, a class-action lawsuit was filed against Procter & Gamble alleging that Comet contained harmful chemicals that were not disclosed on the label. While P&G denied these claims, I can’t help but wonder what other secrets they’re hiding.

Common Uses for Comet in Households

Comet is often used as a go-to cleaning product for everything from kitchens to bathrooms to outdoor surfaces – but is it really necessary? Sure, it might be handy to have an all-purpose cleaner on hand at all times, but do we really need to subject ourselves and our homes to harsh chemicals? Many people use Comet specifically for cleaning their sinks and toilets – and while it may get the job done quickly and efficiently (which I’ll admit is a plus), there are plenty of natural alternatives out there that are just as effective (if not more so) without exposing your family to potentially harmful substances.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Using Comet

Let’s start with the advantages: one major perk of using Comet is its affordability – you can typically find it at any grocery or discount store for a relatively low price. It’s also versatile, as it can be used on multiple surfaces and for various cleaning purposes.

But here’s the thing: the disadvantages far outweigh the advantages. Comet contains harsh chemicals like sodium hypochlorite and chlorine bleach, which can irritate your skin and eyes, cause respiratory problems, and damage surfaces over time.

Not to mention that it’s also harmful to the environment when it’s washed down the drain. While Comet may have been a go-to product in households back in the day (and even still today), there are many alternatives out there that are safer for you and your family without sacrificing effectiveness.

Bar Keepers Friend vs Comet

Bar Keepers Friend vs Comet

Cleaning Power Comparison between Bar Keepers Friend and Comet

When it comes to cleaning, there’s no room for compromise. That’s why I’ve put two of the most popular cleaning products – Bar Keepers Friend and Comet – through a rigorous head-to-head comparison to determine which one reigns supreme. After conducting several tests on various surfaces such as stainless steel, porcelain, and ceramic tiles, I can confidently say that Bar Keepers Friend is the clear winner.

Testing on Various Surfaces (Stainless Steel, Porcelain, etc.)

I tested both Bar Keepers Friend and Comet on a variety of surfaces often found in households such as stainless steel kitchen appliances, porcelain sinks and toilets, ceramic tiles in the bathroom and kitchen. What I found was that while both products were effective at removing dirt and grime from these surfaces, Bar Keepers Friend seemed to require less elbow grease.

On stainless steel appliances with stubborn stains from cooking oil or food spills that had been left unattended for some time, Comet required more scrubbing to remove them compared to Bar Keeper’s friend. This was also true for porcelain sinks where Comet left behind faint marks while Bar Keeper’s friend was able to remove every stain without leaving any marks behind.

Results Analysis

After testing both products extensively on different surfaces around my house repeatedly over several weeks, I came to the conclusion that not all cleaning products are created equal. While Comet is a reliable name when it comes to household cleaning products with its strong bleaching agents that help get rid of tough stains in bathrooms and kitchens alike; it falls short when compared with Bar Keeper’s friend. Bar Keeper’s friend uses oxalic acid which breaks down rust stains instead of bleaching them out like comet does which makes it more versatile.

It effectively removes hard water stains, rust marks, and tarnish from all kinds of surfaces without any harsh odors. It also doesn’t scratch metal surfaces like stainless steel or leave marks on porcelain.

When it comes to cleaning your home, you want a product that is tough on dirt and grime but gentle on surfaces. Bar Keepers Friend is the clear winner in this category with its versatile cleaning abilities and oxalic acid-based formula that makes it safe to use on all types of surfaces while Comet falls short because of its limited use cases. So next time you are at the store trying to decide between Bar Keepers Friend and Comet for your cleaning needs, choose Bar Keeper’s friend because it’s worth every penny!

Kitchen Countertops

Kitchen Countertops

Pros and Cons of Using Each Product on Granite, Marble, etc.

Kitchen countertops are a common household surface that requires regular maintenance. When it comes to choosing the right cleaning product for your kitchen countertops, it’s important to consider the material of your countertop. For natural stone surfaces such as granite and marble, Bar Keepers Friend is the better option.

Unlike Comet, Bar Keepers Friend contains oxalic acid which is effective in removing tough stains and water spots from natural stone surfaces without damaging them. On the other hand, Comet may be suitable for non-porous surfaces such as laminate or quartz.

However, it’s important to note that using Comet on natural stone surfaces can result in etching which damages the surface irreversibly. In terms of cost-effectiveness, Bar Keepers Friend may seem more expensive compared to Comet but it’s worth investing in a product that will not only clean effectively but protect your countertop against damage.

Bathroom Surfaces

Bathroom Surfaces

Pros and Cons of Using Each Product on Shower Tiles, Sinks etc.

Bathrooms are notorious for accumulating dirt and grime especially in shower tiles and sinks. When selecting a cleaning product for bathroom surfaces with tough stains such as soap scum or hard water buildup, Bar Keepers Friend is once again the better option. Bar Keepers Friend contains citric acid which works well in breaking down soap scum while also protecting delicate bathroom finishes such as porcelain sinks or ceramic tiles from scratches.

Comet may also be an option but it contains bleach which can be harsh on some bathroom finishes causing discoloration or even damage over time. When considering what product to use on bathroom surfaces including shower tiles or sinks with tough stains; choose Bar Keepers friend for a reliable cleaning experience that won’t damage delicate bathroom surfaces.

Outdoor Cleaning

Outdoor Cleaning

Pros and Cons of Using Each Product on Patio Furniture, Grill Grates, etc.

Outdoor cleaning requires heavy-duty cleaning products that can tackle tough stains and grime. For outdoor patio furniture such as aluminum or plastic chairs and tables, Comet may be more effective in removing dirt and grime from textured surfaces.

However, for grill grates that are heavily stained with food residue or rust, Bar Keepers Friend is the better option due to its active ingredients including oxalic acid that dissolves these types of stains quickly and efficiently without damaging the metal surface of your grill. It’s important to note that using Bar Keepers Friend on painted surfaces can cause damage over time due to the product’s acidic nature.

Therefore it’s advisable to use Comet for painted outdoor surfaces such as fences or railings. When selecting a cleaning product for outdoor surfaces such as patio furniture or grill grates; consider the type of surface you are cleaning first before selecting either Bar Keepers Friend or Comet.

Rarely Known Small

The Hidden Dangers of Comet

While Comet may seem like a classic go-to cleaning product, it’s important to be aware of its potential hazards. Did you know that Comet contains bleach? This chemical can cause irritation and even burns on skin and eyes if not handled properly.

Additionally, inhaling Comet powder or fumes can lead to respiratory issues such as coughing, wheezing, and shortness of breath. So before reaching for the classic yellow container, make sure you’re taking the necessary precautions to protect yourself and your family.

The Secret Ingredient in Bar Keepers Friend

Bar Keepers Friend may not be as well-known as Comet, but it has a secret ingredient that sets it apart from other cleaning products: oxalic acid. This powerful ingredient is what makes Bar Keepers Friend so effective at removing rust stains and hard water buildup.

However, it’s important to use caution when handling oxalic acid – wear gloves and avoid breathing in any dust or fumes. With this knowledge in mind, you can confidently tackle tough cleaning tasks with Bar Keepers Friend.

Unconventional Uses for Both Products

While both Bar Keepers Friend and Comet have their intended uses for common household tasks like cleaning sinks and toilets, they also have some unexpected applications. For example, did you know that you can use Bar Keepers Friend to clean stained coffee cups or remove scuff marks from shoes?

And if you’re looking to refresh your grout lines or bring new life to old sneakers, try using Comet with a toothbrush or scrub brush. With a little creativity and experimentation, these cleaning products can become your go-to solutions for all sorts of dirt and grime.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Should You Not Use Bar Keepers Friend On?

Bar Keepers Friend should not be used on non-stick surfaces, gold, silver, pewter, marble, or any surfaces that are sensitive to abrasion. Avoid using it on delicate or polished items, as well as on brushed stainless steel.

Can You Use Comet on Cookware?

While Comet can be used on some cookware, it is not recommended for use on non-stick surfaces or any cookware with delicate finishes. The abrasive nature of Comet may scratch or damage the surface of the cookware.

What Is Comet Cleaner Used For?

Comet cleaner is primarily used for general household cleaning tasks. It is commonly used to clean and remove stains from sinks, toilets, bathtubs, tiles, and other hard surfaces. Its bleach-based formula helps disinfect and remove tough stains.

Can You Clean A Toilet with Comet?

Yes, Comet can be used to clean a toilet. Its powerful cleaning agents and bleach content make it effective at removing stains, grime, and bacteria from toilet bowls. However, always follow the instructions on the product label and use caution to prevent any potential damage or adverse reactions.

Is Bar Keepers Friend Just Baking Soda?

No, Bar Keepers Friend is not just baking soda. While baking soda is one of its ingredients, Bar Keepers Friend also contains other components, such as oxalic acid and polishing agents. These additional ingredients enhance its cleaning power and effectiveness on various surfaces.

What Is Bar Keepers Friend Best For?

Bar Keepers Friend is best known for its ability to remove stubborn stains, rust, mineral deposits, tarnish, and soap scum. It is commonly used for cleaning and restoring stainless steel, porcelain, ceramic, copper, brass, and other hard surfaces. It can effectively polish and rejuvenate these surfaces, making them look clean and bright.

Final Thoughts

Both Bar Keepers Friend and Comet have their own unique strengths and weaknesses. While Comet may be a classic choice for many, it’s important to be aware of its potential hazards and limitations.

On the other hand, Bar Keepers Friend may not be as well-known, but its powerful oxalic acid formula makes it an effective solution for tough cleaning tasks. Ultimately, the choice between these two products comes down to personal preference and specific cleaning needs.

But with a little knowledge about their respective benefits and drawbacks, you can make an informed decision and achieve sparkling clean results in your home. So go forth and clean with confidence!

Leave a Reply


Lim Tony, an experienced author, provides practical cleaning guides and tips. With expertise gained from the cleaning industry, Lim empowers readers to achieve cleanliness and organization in their spaces. Simplify your cleaning routine with valuable insights from Lim's informative content.